It Snowballed, One Might Say

Goodness, we must look a fright. It happened when my colleague and I were returning from our morning constitutional, and passed a group of ruffians engaged in a spirited winter’s battle. Now, I might have made one or two mild remarks on the subject of their accuracy, but the response of the barbarians was shockingly out of all proportion. Suffice to say, the question of whether they can hit the broad side of a barn has been conclusively settled.

We stand before you now humbler but wiser for the experience. (Reddit)
You already voted!

Now, I Know This Looks Bad

“But I can explain. That new sofa you brought home wasn’t a sofa at all, but actually Jacques LeSchlaques, notorious furniture impersonator and thief. He was waiting until nightfall to ransack your house, but we knocked the stuffing out of him!”

Dogs stand in front of piles of loose furniture stuffing
There is, we assume, some sort of reward? (Reddit)

Such selfless heroes, Andrew Y.

You already voted!